Last time I cried
I was a little reluctant to post this
essay, because, first of all, this is something about KMLA, and some peers are already
aware of the event I wrote about. And, secondly, I think I was being very weird
at the time when this event happened. Anyway, I want to say that I wrote this
essay as honestly as possible though it might seem weird to some of the
readers.
As my acquaintances might guess, I hate crying in front of others; I hate revealing my emotion in public. I usually dealt with challenging and stressful events in KMLA on my own. And in most cases it worked quite well. However, there are things that perseverance does not help such as trouble in personal relationship. Last year, at the end of the first semester, I cried in front of other person for the first and the last time in KMLA, because of such trouble, though now it seems trivial.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------
It was during Minjok Festival, the most
free day in my junior year. All the stages simply looked fun and excellent to
me; until I received a text message from Mom. During the break, I read the
message.
“Jiseon, you got a bronze prize from the
academic festival! Congratulations!”
It was certainly great news. Then I became
curious about who won the first place. As soon as I read the list of awardees,
I cried out, “Ridiculous, it’s crazy!” The 1st prize was given to four senior
students, whom I sincerely respect as Sunbaes, but whose presentation, I
thought, was a B.S. All the prizes in physics were given to the seniors, except
for me and another member in the physics club. I didn’t want to blame seniors,
but I thought that something was wrong about the result. Most students who watched
the presentations said works of our club were comparatively well done.
Nonetheless, I was not bold enough to argue
with the teachers. Instead, I dug up the criteria of the academic festival
written in 2009 in KMLA Online. The most heavily scored criteria was “creative motive
of the research”, which reminded me of a question I was asked. After my
presentation, one teacher threw me an unexpected question,
“According to your paper, you started
research when you found the interesting phenomenon ‘accidently’ while cleaning
up. Is it true?”
I had prepared for the questions only about
theory and experiment. Honestly, our club members had started the research to
practice for a national competition. We chose topics from the national
competition of last year. I had never imagined that someone would take that
line so seriously. At first I beat around the bush, but later told the truth.
Only after I saw the criteria, I regretted
my answer. But I couldn’t still understand that criterion. ‘What’s so important
about creativity of the subject? Can it represent one’s ideas and perseverance?’
A few days later, Mr. Kim, the instructor of
the club, mentioned about academic festival. He said there were some mistakes,
such as not answering a question honestly. After his comment, he added, “do you
have any question?” I raised my hand unlike usual.
“I think our purpose of research doesn’t
fit with school academic festival.”
He stared at me and said,
“What do you mean?”
I explained that we were bound to choose
the subjects from the competition of last year, so we could not be so creative
about our topic. He frowned and asked again.
“What do you mean?”
I repeated the same response. His face turned
red.
“SO, WHAT DO YOU MEAN?”
He asked me to stand up at the back of the
classroom. He asked me if I was trying to say that the teachers were being
unfair. I only repeated the same answer. My voice started to tremble. He
finally said, “It’s not it. You’re wrong.”
Wrong. That word somehow stabbed my heart.
I wished I could defend myself that I was only telling that we could have been
evaluated better if the criteria were focused on the research itself. That I
was terribly sorry when my peers were not rewarded, who went through equally
difficult moments. But I couldn’t, because I didn’t want to blame others
anymore. I was frustrated that he did not try to understand me. I didn’t mean
to blame anyone; I only wanted to say that the criteria might have been unfair.
After the class, the event replayed in my brain all day long. The next morning, I talked about that
incident again with my advisor. I planned to make it short, but as I started to
talk, I burst into tears. She patiently waited until I found relief. I cannot
remember what my advisor said exactly, but I remember that I felt much more
comfortable after I cried.
It did not take too long to realize how
shortsighted I was. I overlooked my weaknesses, busy blaming external factors.
I could find many errors and flaws in my research paper, after rereading it
carefully. And of course, it was possible for me to find the meaning of the
research, even if the problem was not new; I shouldn’t have lied in any case. I
think I was being unusual and overly sensitive. However, because I expressed my
thought boldly in front of the teacher, because I was bitten so hard, I could
stop, before the small vanity grew any more, and look back on myself.
I understand that a prompt such as this requires much honesty, and I really do appreciate that candor that you present throughout this essay. Nonetheless, this incident, I believe, is very appropriate for the prompt. To criticize, I would have to comment on your delivery of the essay. There were quite some grammatical errors and it could have been delivered much more efficiently.
답글삭제I remember this lol. Many things that seemed so miserable are actually nothing when we reflect back. Funny thing.
답글삭제Honesty is almost always a winner with college essays. You take a cliche sort of "dissapointment/dealing with failure" topic and win it over with your mature treatment of the issue and story. Easily can be much shorter and much more concise without the extra details, and the structure can be played with in multiple drafts. Ultimately, what do you want to tell the reader about yourself? This tells me many things, all fairly positive even if your attitude, at first, needed some reflection. Can easily be a bit more "fun" and even more honest and testimonial. Some details need to be cut out while others need to be included and accounted for. More resolution needed for lingering details.
답글삭제